Welcome to Uncle Joe's Pizza
At Uncle Joe's Pizza, we celebrate the richness of Italian cuisine in a warm, family-oriented setting. Located on Lake Grove's Middle Country Road, our brand story is rooted in tradition and community. Each dish, from our renowned Stracciatella Romano soup to our expert pasta creations, highlights the freshness of ingredients and intricate flavors. Guests rave about our signature pizzas with perfectly cooked crusts, whether they seek a classic or a Sicilian delight. Our attentive staff fosters a welcoming atmosphere, making every visit special. Join us for a memorable dining experience that feels like coming home.
-
2854 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755, United States Hotline: +1 631-981-0690
Welcome to Uncle Joe's Pizza, a cherished gem nestled at 2854 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY. This delightful Italian restaurant has quickly carved out a reputation for itself, enticing the local community and visitors alike with a menu brimming with authentic flavors and exceptional dishes.
The first thing to note about Uncle Joe's is the rich array of offerings. From classic pizzas to mouth-watering pasta dishes, every item is crafted with care. Patrons rave about their experiences, highlighting their favorite dishes:
- Penne Puttanesca - A hearty dish featuring olives, onions, fresh garlic, and capers in a delectable plum tomato sauce for $17.00.
- Linguini Carbonara - Creamy and indulgent, with sautéed onions, peas, and bacon for $18.00.
- Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe And Sausage - A flavorful dish of sausage sautéed with garlic and broccoli rabe, priced at $20.00.
- Baked Ziti - A classic Sicilian comfort food, generously served for just $16.00.
But it’s not just the pasta that shines here; the pizzas at Uncle Joe's have won the hearts (and stomachs) of many. Visitors like Camaron A praise the Sicilian style pizza for its perfect crust and remarkable sauce that balances tenderness and flavor flawlessly. “The crust… my God, the crust!” Steven Lepore exclaimed, further emphasizing how everything at Uncle Joe's is made with freshness in mind.
Equally impressive is Uncle Joe's inviting ambiance and community vibe, often highlighted in reviews. Dining here feels like joining a gathering of friends and family, led by a genuinely welcoming staff that includes the owner and their children. This familial dedication is palpable, creating a warm environment where customers feel appreciated and valued.
Customer experiences confirm that the overall dining experience at Uncle Joe's extends beyond just food; it’s about genuine hospitality. Blake Cunzio noted that while enjoying the delicious pasta, he felt as though he was dining at a five-star establishment, thanks to the attentive service and vibrant setting.
Whether you’re hosting a special event like a baptism, as shared by Gina Mitrani, or simply indulging in a casual meal with family and friends, Uncle Joe’s Pizza stands out as a top choice in Lake Grove. With a robust menu, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to quality, it’s clear that Uncle Joe's will only continue to rise in popularity.
So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Uncle Joe's Pizza. Dive into a slice of happiness—your taste buds will thank you!
Food was wonderful. Pasta night is the best deal for italian pasta. Bread was amazing. Coffee was also great which came with my meal and also dessert amazing. Staff was super polite very attentive. Water was filled 3 times which is awsome and i felt like i dined 5 star. Plenty of room 16 full tables. Super classy and great prices that cant be matched .
New spot to come to. Excellent sauce, undercarriage is perfect. Fidel will make you feel welcome customer service is amazing. I go all over L.I for best pizza and this is quickly climbing the ranks! Thanks Fidel and team! -Marco
We had our sons baptism in the back room with 60 people and everything was perfect. The food was amazing! The staff went ABOVE AND BEYOND! Highly recommend! Also, we order take out all the time and the food is always amazing!
Been coming here since the late 80s. We have had food catered here and always the food is top notch. Hard to find a pizzeria that executes great pizza and Italian entrees and appetizers. On my recent family visit to the island, I always try to make here for at least a few slices. I'm a Sicilian pizza purist, just the basics for me and their Sicilian is in my top 10 on the island and I've eaten at more pizzerias than I should divulge . The crust is cooked perfectly, crispy but not overdone. More than ample amount of creamy cheese and my favorite part is the sauce. The sauce is in a league of its own, perfect balance of acidity and sweetness, it has a distinctive taste that is hard to duplicate. If they sold fried sauceballs, I'd fly up from Tampa, just for that. If all these accolades weren't enough, the people here are nothing short of amazing. Warm, friendly and inviting, people you look forward to seeing. Place has a community vibe like it's Bay Ridge not middle country rd in Lake Grove. Looking forward to my next trip back to the island and next time, stopping in lunch and trying one of thier delicious daily specials.
Really liked the peperoni roll, and the pizza was loaded with cheese... excellent undercarriage and good quality ingredients. Inside of the restaurant was freezing but I won't hold that against them.
We came for dinner, party of 7, everything was delicious and reasonably priced. Family owned and operated. Wonderful atmosphere & holiday decorated. We sat in the large back room of the restaurant, could easily host an intimate bridal/baby shower. Garlic knots, calamari, mozzarella sticks, eggplant parm, chicken franchise, cannolis, everything is very good, portion sizes are huge, service is great. Highly recommend!
The crust… my God, the crust! This has to be some of the best pizza on the Island. The crust is so thin and crispy but it’s not dry or burnt. Everything tastes fresh. Absolutely delicious! I’ve had the regular pie as well as a few different specialty slices and they’re all incredible. The staff is also so friendly and attentive. I can’t wait to come back again!
This is a wonderful family owned Italian restaurant. Mom, Dad, Son and Daughter are always smiling when you walk in... Probably the most genuinely nice people you can meet... The food is excellent, plentiful and fresh... The inventive pizzas are incredible... If you're in the area try it... Love this place...